Yes carvakan I agree with you.
It seems to me a high fantasy guide would be very valuable as long as it keeps intact coherence and ArM flavor.
[url]https://forum.atlas-games.com/t/three-books-lacking-to-arm/3150/1]
One reason amongst others that made me unconfortable with ME is the status of the Divine. You have well exposed an aspect of this problem in another thread and I follow you totally on this ground.
In a high fantasy setting such issues would be avoided as well as the other complex issue of the future of ME.
I'd like to add I love A&A and particularly the way aristotelician and platonician cosmologies (that i have discovered there as i m a scientist) are decribed. A high fantasy guide should be cautious the way it changes this cosmology.