I'm having trouble following some parts in your last post.
You often use alternative terms for some of the game terms, which makes it hard to follow. For example:
- You use "Experemental genius" instead of "Inventive Genius". That's confusing.
- Is "Experimental roll" the roll on the "Extraordinary Results Chart"?
Please be more precise, that will help us a lot! 
Also, the Experimentation Bonus (12 in this case) should be divided between the various Components. Right now the total adds up to 17 instead of 12. Once you have corrected the proposed bonuses I will make a call on the appropriatedness of each. Edit: That is incorrect - I just re-read the text and the bonus is "used" up as you determine which components provide a bonus.
The Risk Factor is not added to the rolls on the Side Effect table.
Note that you still haven't posted the final stats of you magus at the time of Gauntlet in his final stats topic. Makes it hard for us to be sure what the stats are that you are using. Please do so as soon as you can.