charter discussion thread

Retired Play by Post Campaigns Ars Magica 5th Edition: A Sudden Spring
41

Argentius listens to Zarkut thoughtfully and then nods.

"I agree with you in principle, Zarkut. My suggestion of a reaffirming our original commitment to the Charter was intended as a symbolic and public statement of our commitment to each other."

The artificer looks around the group.

"We are all responding to this change in different ways. For some, we consider this a new beginning and feel no ties to our former selves. For others, we feel we are the same person. For others we feel dutybound to that former self. Perhaps we simply gather together and publicly and verbally reaffirm for each other our commitment to the Charter and to each other."

42

"I understand your ... fundamental objection, I think, magus Zarkut," Plasmatoris says, idly pushing away the sketch he had been working on and reaching for a drink. "The urge to addendum the charter, and re-sign it is most likely based on the sense that we need to resolidify our brotherhood. Our bound purpose. Oaths have power." He sips at the wine, and frowns at it. He performs a quick incantation to alter its flavor subtly, and returns to sipping.

"We want to addendum the charter, rather than just re-sign the same thing, because we are magi, and we create things. We forge our path and we are masters of our own destiny. We have a sense of hubris in our existence, just by the powers we wield." Plasmatoris gives Zarkut a wide grin. "Magi are less likely to agree to someone else's terms than to dictate their own. Even when we agree to another's ideas, we will want to add our own words." He lifts his wine, studying the cup.

"The charter is a symbol, as you said. And we are all strangers, in a land of risk and opportunity, and surrounded by trouble and turmoil. The charter can be a strong symbol. And that is why I decided to join this conversation. I have been living here, a highly-honored guest of the former magi of this covenant, and as such I have striven to show my good will and good grace. Even if we stand at odds about philosophical differences."

Plasmatoris comes to a halt, his gaze drifting back to Argentius. He frowns thoughtfully, staring at the other magus for a few breaths, before he adds, "I started rambling again." Then he shrugs, and sits back.

"We're here to discuss the charter, and Magus Zarkut's opinion is we don't need to change a thing. It's a valid opinion, and one with strong moral arguments. The important thing is at the end of the discussion, we all are satisfied with our collective work."

1 Like
43

Tastheus takes time to listen to his sodals. Every point of view is important to him and necessary to solve problems. As he goes through the various documents already drafted, he smiles. He notices that his way of thinking is still the one he has slowly and longingly forged.

"Yes, I am indeed a quaesitor, even if my knowledge is not as deep as it once was."

Tastheus looks around at all the members present for a bit before giving his opinion:
"I would differentiate between legal and social on this matter; as well as between re-signing and adding or even changing points in the existing charter."

He straightens up a bit, his back straight, trying to look more confident and strict than he really is. But he knows that appearances can be deceptive as well as influential.

"From a purely legal and quaesitorial point of view, there is no reason to sign this charter again. Although some people prefer to think of themselves as new people, our sigils remain what they are, as do our souls. We are what we were and the signature we put at the bottom of the current charter commits us as it did on the day it was signed.

He let a few seconds pass, the time to measure his words before resuming:
"However, I understand perfectly well that, since our memories have disappeared, some people are asking for the commitment to be made again. Whether it's because they feel it makes us a new person or to re-anchor it in our memories. I for one see no problem with this request and even support it."

He rereads all the documents a little, thereby giving his sodals an opportunity to react to his words, before coming to the second part and the proposals made.

1 Like
44

Silas who has been thoughtfully nodding along to the conversation thus far, licks his lips before he raises his voice.

“Sodales, it has been made quite clear to me that I may have been overzealous with my first draft. Such is the plight of any creator. Each new task he wants to rediscover the very wheel. It despite being quite sound, if I say so myself, was not suited for our needs. I will concur to this – since it’s what the majority believes. But I will hold that at least some of the points should be kept and resigned.”

Silas pulls out the old draft and folds it out on the carpet in front of him. Pointing to the clauses as he speaks.

“Clause one and two are both important to me. Let’s make this fresh start as true as it could ever be. Right now, we are all equal and have no reason to feud with one another. So, let’s sign this all together affirming that such is the case.”

45

Argentius listens to his fellow artificer with an attentive expression. When Silas is done, Argentius simply nods.

"I have no issues with the first two clauses. They speak to the loyalty and common cause they we all need to reinforce and build."

The handsome artificer looks at the others and then gestures to Tastheus.

"I would like to hear Tastheus's thoughts on how best to implement this addendum. Perhaps there is an alternative to modifying the Charter and letting us sign an ancillary agreement that invokes our commitment to Magus Silas's two clauses."

46

Zarkut nods. "The first two clauses I find less objectionable, reaffirming principles, and I don't mind that as we do have no memory of each other, so it would perhaps set all our minds at ease. Though the second sentence of the second clause is a bit vague, the word loyal is left hanging. And I wouldn't mind some reference to our situation and keeping it secret, though not such a point-by-point breakdown of duties."

1 Like
47

Plasmatoris's attention had been crawling through the original Charter agreement, glancing up now and again as the others speak. To Silas, he gives a broad smile. The Jerbiton seems incapable of small polite smiles anymore than he is of small moods. He gives a few nods as the man speaks of the passion a creator can be captured by. He certainly understands that.

To Tastheus, the man frowns a bit, thoughtful, his bright eyes going distant. "I won't get into the specific arguments again about definitions and dismissive treatment. Needless to say, I feel something should be done to resolidify our position. To re-bind us all. I have no plans to turn away here, and do not expect it out of anyone, but there is a purity in codified purpose."

Plasmatoris looks over to Argentius and then Zarkut, his expression thoughtful. "We don't even really need it to be an official charter, do we? Just an affirmation of goal and purpose. 'We the undersigned, magi of this covenant, do hereby reaffirm our support of the covenant. To ward away strife and conflict, and build a better, more profitable future collectively. For reasons of our own we have come together stronger than we have been before, and forge a path ahead together, guarding the shared secrets of our magic and our covenant.'" Plasmatoris shrugs lazily and reaches for another drink. "Magi in Thebes have been known to work together in magical leagues, and I understand Flambeaux and others often agree to guard each others' secrets with agreements of brotherhood." He pushes the Charter back into the center of the table and leans back, sipping his drink. "It doesn't need to be in the charter, necessarily, but an agreement of working together. That would help my spirits, I think. My real worry here is the assertion of onus in carrying another's name."

1 Like
48

"I agree, Plasmatoris. It quite likely doesn't need to be a change to the Charter at all. It could just be an agreement, like you said, that is ancillary to the Charter given the situation we find ourselves in," says Argentius with a nod.

"It feels to me like we're making progress toward a consensus. Do others feel the same?"

49

Zarkut nods, looking around for the others' reactions.

50

"I think we are indeed moving towards a consensus. As I said, there is a difference between the official version that I represent as a quaestor and the human will that we have to reaffirm our link. I am totally in favour of a joint declaration. "

He smiles at his sodals. He does not seek to oppose the others, but to complement their vision towards a new one.

"We could work in two parts. First a simple affirmation of reaffirmation of the covenant, as Plasmatorius proposed. Secondly, a revision of the original charter. We all seem to be broadly in agreement that adding the first two points will further affirm the equality between the eight of us."

51

Argentius smiles softly, almost inwardly, as he looks over at Tastheus, and then at the others gathered in the breezeway outside his sanctum.

"It sounds like we are agreed. I propose that Tastheus, as quesitor, take the lead in organizing our affirmation and revision. Does anyone second this proposal?"