[GotF] are Philipus' Niger's Vim spells to general?

[Tellus]

@Christian Andersen

But the core ArM5 rules says for Perdo Vim guidelines specifically that Unravelling is to "Dispell magic of a specific type...Hermetic Terram magic of Shamanistic spirit control magic..."

OK, I suppose that strictly speaking they were never OK s they had only a single identifier rather than the 2 indecated by the guidelines as necessary.

The Rego Vim guidelines for suppresing magic came in HoH:Soc, which may very well have come out after GotF,
I know the specifics of Rune magic and other Hedge traditions came later. But the general rules predate all.

I was rather thinking of HMRE (and Rival Magics) if that was unclear.

As long as the Troupe cna agree on how broad or specific to define such magics it is all fine I guess. It does sound excessive to need a new Unravelling for each Rune, there are so bloody many of them! OTOH it makes sense that the OoO is the Order's boogeyman...

I must admit I don't really find it that excessive. Annoying perhaps, but that's about it.