[Also posted to the BerkList]
I'm just writing to let people know that I recently finally got sent
my copy of HoH: Societas, and had a read through.
Authors in Ars get very little credit. They don't get much of the way
of congratulations or feedback, or criticism (there is some, but not
much).
So, I'm writing to say that I enjoyed HoH:S a great deal.
In particular, I thought the Tytalus section was evocative - the leper
magus and the conflicts. Not too sure about how Tasgillia was
presented (ie, the Tytalans aren't too apologetic about her??). Also,
if there is so much writing on Tytalus (letters, diaries, etc), why is
there a lot of mystery over the history of the Order, particularly to
do with whether the Founders were as powerful as their Hermetic
predecessors?
I liked the Flambeau stuff, but was disappointed to see an unnecessary
revision of earlier material regarding the death of Flambeau himself.
Why was this decision made? I smacks of the unnecessary edit to the
Primus of House Tremere (which Timothy and I have discussed before).
Not really sure about the "schools" - they are basically character
concepts?
The Jerbiton section was interesting regarding the links to Greece,
but I felt the culture of the House then did not follow through. I
would have liked to see what happens when you use Greek to cast
Hermetic magic (did I miss that?). How did the Jerbiton manage to
fight off House Tremere?
Didn't get into much of the Ex Misc stuff.
Apart from that, I also want to commend Atlas for the quality of the
art, which, with a few exceptions, was of good to high quality.