Magical Focus: Communication

Hail sodales! I'm currently refining my magus concept for my first saga. He's a Guernicus Quaesitor whose long term goal is to fix the Rhine Corruption. While my concept came quickly, I've struggled with my Virtues and Flaws. Especially the Hermetic ones.

I figured that a Magical Focus would be a good way to give him something to differentiate himself from other Guernicus magi, especially since he's an Intellego specialist. Hardly playing against type.

Before I gave into my love of Intellego, I was planning on being a Terram specialist. I initially considered a stonework oriented focus, I then thought: what if I played Columbo but a wizard? A detective focused on social interactions and interrogations. Not of mundanes, I don't want to step on the Gentle Gifted covenant member's toes.

Rather, an interrogator of everyday objects. I noticed that most Intellego combinations include an option to speak to things you normally can't. Animals and plants as one would expect. But also fires, rivers, and stones. Thus I settled on a major magical focus themed around speech/communication.

Please provide your feedback. Is this a good idea? I'm concerned about accidentally breaking the prohibition on scrying because a doorknob told me something delicate. Unlike other Intellego spells, Forceless Casting doesn't really help. Furthermore, is this too broad of a focus? I know that things as broad as Damage or Disguise are valid foci but is this suitable?

If Major Focus Communication/Speech (still deliberating on the specific name) isn't suitable then would a focus in spirits be good? Spirits would cover all of my talking to objects spells and then some. Plus it'd also cover the Quaesitorial spell: Dream of the Mind that Sits alongside Dream of Artifice etc.

My opinions: Communication is a large Major Magical Focus, but okay. It's smaller than the Art of Intellego, though it does do the permitted thing of reaching beyond that Art: e.g. Words of the Unbroken Silence is CrMe, and seems legit.

I would pick it over Spirits both because it seems more interesting, and easier to manage rules-wise. E.g. you don't have to worry about what exactly is a spirit or which Realms are covered.

If I were your GM, I might limit it to spells that make communication possible, not easier. So no Aura of Ennobled Presence, or CrMe ritual spells to permanently increase Com score. But that's a troupe decision, I think.

Your concerns about accidental scrying are valid, but I think that's a problem every Quaesitor has to deal with, and they have rules about how to do it. Don't let that put you off getting a shabby trenchcoat. You can always say John Constantine gave it to you.

Set the expectations with troupe/SG

Canon wise, scrying is mostly a trivial crime, not worth the time of a quasitor and for most, not even a fine. Some "victims" will push for a certamen and get something from you that way.

Scrying with the intent of stealing a magical secret is more serious and could get you in good trouble. Heavy fine or loss of a talisman/familiar are in play.

Scrying where you uncover a magical secret by accident is bad. Similar to above. Will greatly depend on the secret, the quasitor, your standing, etc.

Scrying with the intent of uncovering a magical secret and being successful at it is the canon exemple of what gets you convicted of a high crime and marched!

Factors that attenuate the crime. If you are yourself trying to resolve a crime and the scrying was made in that context. If the target is not in good standing and suspected of crimes. For example, you scry on a suspected infernalist and uncover he has means to communicate with demons. You uncovered a magical secret using magical scrying but it is unlikely, if you can prove it, that it will lead to you being condemned of a high crime

Hope it helps,

W

I had a character concept along similar lines, in case it's useful for ideas: Talky Guernicus. In my case I used the minor magical focus "Enabling Communication".

As usual with Magical focus, the name of the focus is only to shorten the scope of it. You should describe what the focus should cover, with spells example and what it should not. Based on that, it will be easier to assess the minor/major focus parameters and refine what will fit in.

Good point Ezechiel. I think Salutor captured the gist of what I had originally intended with the concept of "Enabling Communication": spells that enable you to speak with inanimate objects, animals, or plants. Salutor apparently built that as a minor magical focus.

Michael had interpreted my proposed major focus to encompass these "translation" spells alongside CrMe spells that let you speak into someone's mind directly like Words of Unbroken Silence. You could probably argue that the broader major focus could include ReIm spells which move your voice.

I think my original idea would be more concisely described as "Speaking to Inanimate Objects". Inanimate Objects specifically because one of my covenmates is an Animal specialist and I dislike redundancy. Whereas the broader but related focus concept would be "Speech" concerning words, talking, etc.

I had not intended for my focus to relate to the Communication characteristic nor buff spells for it, despite the original name perhaps implying that.

Thanks a ton for the input on scrying. I think the nuanced and granular interpretation makes a lot of sense, particularly regarding intent and results. Scrying and finding out about a magus' breakfast is not equivalent to learning about a magus' research or mystery cult.

I'm just a bit cautious because I plan on playing my Quaesitor as a Traditionalist and I'd prefer not to come across as overreaching. Especially considering my ambitious political aims.

Thanks for the link Salutor. I think your concept closely matches my original idea for my Quaesitor and focus: interrogator who specializes in talking to things instead of people.

I see you took "Enabling Communication" as a minor focus. Does that solely cover talking to animals and objects or does that also include things like telepathy or "sending" spells. I.e. ReIm projecting your voice's species to a person or distant place. I originally only intended for the former but it'd be nice to also have the latter.

I'm curious to hear your reasoning on the scope. Of course, this is all subject to my guide and troupe. But this is their first saga also, so that's why I made this thread. To get some perspective from more experienced Ars players.

I'd been largely thinking of it applying to the various "Speak with X" spells, but it's more a case of "I hadn't considered" mental / distance communication than "I'd decided it didn't apply".

Purely "speak with X" spells is quite a narrow focus, so I think it could reasonably be broadened, but you'd need to make sure the communication remained the overwhelming feature of the spell. For example, I wouldn't allow "Image from the Wizard Torn" to count for it just because your displaced image could speak to someone, but it seems reasonable to allow a spell that creates a whisper in someone's ear. Maybe a restriction that the only information you should be gaining is deliberate communication from the subject of the spell?

I was thinking that specifying it solely applies to "Enabling Verbal Communication" would solve the issue. No visual images. That also probably removes any Mentem applicability but that was never the original goal. I think gives the focus a fair amount of specificity on par with "creating stonework" or self-transformation. Does that seem reasonable for a minor focus?

I think your description above: "Speaking to Inanimate Objects" would be a reasonable Minor Magic Focus. You get about ten spells out of it, all closely related, and with overlap of where they are useful.

My reservation there is that it's not clear that speaking to e.g. a rock does result in actual verbal communication that other people can hear, as opposed to some sort of mental communion. So you might not be including the key point of the focus.

Apologies for the long delay! You make an excellent point. Especially since the Herbam version of "Speak to X" explicitly points out that bystanders can't parse your conversation. I think it'd be expedient to hone the focus down to spells that enable communication with Inanimate Objects like Tomaso suggested. That way the medium of the communication is secondary and the target is front and center.