Question about rules, Attribution of expérience

[Ovarwa]

Hi,

@Christian Andersen

@Ovarwa

@silveroak

keep in mind that you can write tractatus for abilities as well, and one every 2 levels or fraction thereof- so at level 5 you can write three tractatus. If you have another player who also has a 5 they can write 3 and you trade...

Yeah, but if the Ability you want to do this with is something that only 6 people in Mythic Europe have, say, what you get from an Ex Misc tradition, this strategy doesn't work that well. Especially if the tradition doesn't cultivate awesome writers.

Tell me about it. I currently play a maga of the Line of Pralix. Advancing in Comprehend Magic is difficult at best. Only viable solution is spending Story Exp in it, and if there is some convoluted limit capping this at 5 you're at a huge disadvantage. Although my maga reaching 5 is years if not a full decade away!

Exposure with an Affinity can also work. Practice is meh. So yeah. A lot of work.

I admit that I don't understand the SG's intent, just the actual effects.

I'd more understand a rule that banned story xp from being used on Arts, like old school AM.

Anyway,

Ken

[Tellus]

@Christian Andersen

Tell me about it. I currently play a maga of the Line of Pralix. Advancing in Comprehend Magic is difficult at best. Only viable solution is spending Story Exp in it, and if there is some convoluted limit capping this at 5 you're at a huge disadvantage. Although my maga reaching 5 is years if not a full decade away!

To quote a teacher now dead:

Plactice, plactice, plactice!

• his english was not always the best mind you.

@Ovarwa

I'd more understand a rule that banned story xp from being used on Arts, like old school AM.

You mean; back when Arts weren't based on XPs? Those were the days, I agree.

[Ovarwa]

Hi,

@Tellus

@Christian Andersen

Tell me about it. I currently play a maga of the Line of Pralix. Advancing in Comprehend Magic is difficult at best. Only viable solution is spending Story Exp in it, and if there is some convoluted limit capping this at 5 you're at a huge disadvantage. Although my maga reaching 5 is years if not a full decade away!

To quote a teacher now dead:

Plactice, plactice, plactice!

• his english was not always the best mind you.

@Ovarwa

I'd more understand a rule that banned story xp from being used on Arts, like old school AM.

You mean; back when Arts weren't based on XPs? Those were the days, I agree.

I'm not saying I'd agree. I like the idea of generous story xp, and don't think the current rules for story xp applying to Arts are a problem.

(Applying AM2 vs AM5 Art development rules to a simulation create different results, but that's a different matter, which I've blathered about in the past. I might have also blathered about it in the future, but I'm not aware of that yet.)

Anyway,

Ken

[Sauryan]

From one my fellow member of the troupe i heard my Sg was not such a fan of the 4th edition but he is afraid of some ability in the 5 th so he tend to stick to the 4th on some rules in the end

Out of question
For you guys the minor virtue luck what is it suppose to do ?
When a ligthning storm fall you arent touch when the rest is ( which never happend tbh)

or when you do experimentation you can add +1 or -1 to to your final result ?