Hello all,
I am starting a new saga in Provence at the beginning of the 13th century. As I want the saga to be affected by the Albigensian Crusade I want to decide what the supernatural forces behind this event really are. If we stick to the medieval church paradigm it is relatively easy. The Cathars are manipulated by Infernal forces and it is just to rout them out as well as any who is helping them (a draconian interpretation of the Bible, as was done at the time, would support this view).
From a more modern point of view the Cathars seem very humane, sympathetic and indeed more "good" than the Catholic Church at the time so making the Crusade Infernal and the Cathars divine makes more sense. This also works better with the ArM canon where the people behind the Crusades often are portrayed as evil/Infernal and the Cathar believers good/Divine (see ArM 2, ”A Medieval Tapestry” and ”Mistridge”).
If we do look at the gnostic teachings of the Cathars it is clearly heretic from a Christian point of view. God/Jaweh/Saklas as the creator of the world is an evil deceiver who uses the catholic church to enslave mankind and to stop them to go to the real heaven. The Pope is really Anti-christ. If we accept the Cathars as divine the Church really must be infernal. But that is not true to ArM canon either.
We could say that the Cathars actually belong to the Magic Realm. Indeed, that is what I am supposed to do as they are neither Infernal nor Divine as I see it. The problem with that though is that the dualistic faith of the Cathars is supposed to be about the next life and the existence beyond the material world. The don't seem to believe in miracles – they just want to behave good so that their soul don't have to be reborn to this world. Dragons, ghosts and fireballs seem to be the wrong realm for them and magic (for some reason) is unable to work outside the lunar sphere.
Should we bring back the ”Realm of Reason” from ArM 3 or invent a new one – the Gnostic realm?
A penny for your thoughts and ideas.
Cheers,
Jakob Ryngen