I've got a tribunal coming up which thanks to a combination of ongoing plot and PC shenanigans has quite a few legal cases coming before it. I therefore thought I'd run them past the forum to see how people thought they'd go. Some of them may be more clear cut than others...
The game is set in a version of Stonehenge, although it's been tweaked a bit from the default (in particular, Blackthorn are the dominent political force, with various sections of the tribunal not being well disposed towards them, but are 5th Edition Tremere rather than 4th Edition Tremere).
Case Group 1 - Coenwulf of Bjornaer of Horsingas (Loch Leagan) against a Stonehenge Flambeau and Tremere
Accusations:
Coenwulf: Attempting to Slay a Magus, Interference with Mundanes
Flambeau: Attempting to Slay a Magus
Tremere: Attempting to Slay a Magus, Deprivation of Magical Power, Scrying
The facts
Rumours had been passing through the Redcap network that a boar was attacking mundanes in an area in the north of the Lake District. The Flambeau suggested to Blackthorn that this was something that should be dealt with, and a member of that covenant travelled with them to the location of the attacks. Both magi claim that they didn't know that the boar was a magus, but admit that they knew it was a possibility, Horsingas having been responsible for a number of crossborder raids in recent years.
Having located the wood where the attacks were occurring, the Tremere sent magical birds to scout for the boar. Once found, they set out to confront it. The Flambeau was a Ramian, and therefore dressed as a mundane knight, and upon sighting him the boar immediately charged him and attempted to kill him. The Flambeau being as tough as you'd expect a Ramian to be, the boar largely just bounced, and was then incapacitated by the Tremere (who had followed a little way behind, such that they were not immediately visible upon the boar coming across the armoured knight).
The Tremere and Flambeau then had the opportunity to kill the boar, but instead transported him back to Blackthorn, where he was treated with True Rest of the Injured Brute, but not ritual magic, and not released until the Quaesitors intervened.
The defences:
The Tremere and Flambeau argue that a) they can't be accused of trying to slay Coenwulf given that it was clearly within their power to do so and they didn't, and b) Coenwulf had forfeited his immunity by his attacks on mundanes, which have grown to a sufficient level that they had heard about them from half a country away.
Coenwulf does not attend the tribunal. Instead, his (maga) wife, Ealwynn, argues that a) the Stonehenge tribunal does not have the right to try Aonghas (as she insists Coenwulf should now be named), as alleged crimes in border areas should be tried in the defendant's home tribunal, b) the mundanes Aonghas was attacking were in the process of destroying an area of pristine wilderness, and there are significant precedents in the Order as to the importance of protecting such areas (for example, the Guardians of the Forest ruling in the Rhine tribunal), c), Although there were rumours of him attacking people, they were of a boar doing so and not a magus, and no ruin was brought upon his sodales, d) Aonghas did not know that the knight he was attacking was actually a magus and e) in any case the Flambeau had forfeited his immunity by coming to attack him.
Case Group 2 - The Stabbing of a Tytalus, and the aftermath thereof
Accusations:
Ex-Misc Pharmacopian (Gently Gifted): Attempting to Slay a Magus
Tytalus (Normally Gifted, Inspirational, new to the covenant): Interfering with Mundanes, Endangering the Order
The facts:
The ex-Misc and the Tytalus had been on a mission to slay a magical beast that was raiding their vis source. In preparation for the fight, the magi had created a defensible position around the vis source whilst they waited for it to be harvestable. When the magical beast arrived, the more reckless of the grogs ran outside the defenses to attack the creature directly, and was promptly swallowed. On seeing this, the Tytalus ordered another of the grogs to go and rescue him, and when he flatly refused, used Enslave the Mortal Mind on him to mindcontrol him into doing so.
The Ex-Misc followed the mind-controlled grog out, and levitated him out of the way. The reckless grog successfully cut himself out of the magical beast and slew it, in recognition of which feat the Tytalus "knighted" him.
At sunset, Enslave the Mortal Mind wore off, and the grog was suspicious and confused about what had happened up until the Ex Misc told him exactly what had happened, at which point he punched the Tytalus. The Tytalus demanded his hand in retribution, which the Ex-Misc refused to allow him to take, offering his own hand instead. However, after the Tytalus only grazed him with his inexpert swing, he told him he wasn't going to give him another ago. At this point the Tytalus challenged him to Certamen, demanding that he be allowed to take the grog's hand if he won, and offering to forget the incident if he lost. The Ex-Misc refused to fight a certamen with the grog's hand at stake. [A case of failing to respect Certamen was settled outside the tribunal.]
There was some back and forth, with the Tytalus continuing to demand the formerly mind-controlled grog's hand, and the ex-Misc warning said grog that he knew the Tytalus' type, and that if he wasn't very careful he'd end up killing him, and probably his family as well, and that really if the Tytalus was going to continue to demand that he had the right to take his hand he should just kill him.
At which point the grog stabbed the Tytalus, and came within a hair's breath of killing him. The "knight" grog hastily defended him, and the Ex-Misc hastily protested that he hadn't actually meant kill him when he said the grog should kill him, and stabilised him. They then went back to the covenant where the mind-controlled grog was rapidly sent far away from the covenant, and the magus ritually healed. The Ex-Misc then went on a pilgrimage to Canterbury to the shrine of Thomas a Beckett. He therefore missed most of what came next, other than the trial at the end.
The Tytalus told the "knight" grog that he had returned from death itself "and you know who else did that, don't you?", before talking about the great divine work he needed to carry out. His grog then went out and recruited a small cult dedicated to the second coming of the messiah, and arranged for the magus to come and talk to them. Unfortunately in his enthusiasm (and recklessness), he wasn't very careful about who he invited, with the result that the church found out almost immediately afterwards. The covenant is sited in the middle of church lands, and usually has a fairly close relationship with the church.
The rest of the covenant responded by trying to co-operate ferociously with the church, and painting the Tytalus as one bad apple rather than reprensentative of magi. A senior maga in the covenant then took the "knight" grog down to explain to the church quite what had been happening "I'm not supposed to talk about how he promised to make me a bishop", and the Tytalus was sent his first summons to a canon court, which he ignored. The church started preaching sermons on False Prophets. The Tytalus was ordered by the Guernicus who had come to investigate the Ex-Misc issue to resolve the issue now, and that the church would want him to repent, before hiking off to try to find the Ex-Misc on his pilgrimage.
The Tytalus insisted that this was all a misunderstanding that could be sorted out if the abbot would just come to the covenant for a chat, and holding an evening with free beer for the local townspeople (which ended up having relatively few people turn up who, due to some combination of the sermons and the church presence there). The abbot refused to see him anywhere other than the abbey, and he eventually turned up, attempted to persuade the abbot that this was all a big misunderstanding and then, apparently, cast something on the abbot that failed to penetrate his divine protection.
He did turn up to his third summons (having been warned he'd be tried in astentia if he didn't), at which most of the rest of the covenant (or at least, those who were Gently Gifted) gave character witness statements that were unflattering to various degrees. He defended himself by pointing out that he never actually claimed to be the Messiah, and that he just meant that God had a purpose for him, which he felt sure was his life's mission of helping the poor. "And if helping the poor is blasphemous, then yes, I am a blasphemer".
He got excommunicated.
The defenses
The Ex-Misc argues that he hadn't actually meant the grog to kill him when he said to kill him, having only said it for rhetorical effect, but appreciates that it was a terribly poor choice of wording, and throws himself on the mercy of the tribunal, offering to pay any penalty they set him (save that he has already agreed with the church that he will spend the next year doing good works).
The Tytalus argues that he's been horribly misunderstood, but has proven his good nature by not bringing charges against those magi who blackened his name to the church.