So, a character I'm currently playing is an archetypical bonisagus lab rat (Puissant MT, Affinity MT, Cautious MT, Mythic Int, Inventive Genius) - after a few seasons of play, he can automatically get the 18+ on a die roll to gain an insight from an available text.
The question is: what does he get from reading standard Hermetic texts written by Hermetics with Hermetic virtues? Is he able to pick up on (say) their Flexible Formulaic magic, or their Gentle Gift, just by reading their lab notes? Or does it need to be something specific (such as studying a Jerbiton teaching Gentle Gift to an apprentice) in order to actually gain insight on the targeted Virtue?
My initial thought was "No, you need to study something that specifically targets that specific virtue" such as the aforementioned teaching. Obviously studying someone ELSE's attempt to develop integration of hermetic virtues is also a way. But it doesn't sound right to say that you could gain insight from ANYTHING they wrote (such as their longevity ritual, or something irrelevant to the virtue.)
Maybe something more targeted? Ie, you can potentially gain insight for Flexible hermetic magic by specifically reading a Flexible Hermetics's formulaic lab texts, or an Elementalist's Ignem summae.
Or, maybe no: you have to go back to the original sources (Elementalism hedge texts) to gain real insight. But in that case, what about purely Hermetic ones? Is it just original research at that point?
My view is that a text will have insight about what is necessary to write it. Elemental Magic, Flexible Formulaic Magic and Gentle Gift aren't required for texts, and there is no written insight about it. Hermetic theurgy and numerology are entirely different matters! Lab texts would have insight that could be incorporated. Generic lab texts will mostly incorporate concepts from hermetic magic theory, which is useless to hermetic, but that a folk witch could try and pick up on.
Anything that can be taught can yield insight. Teaching Gentle Gift may be RAW per apprentice, but I expect the average table to prioritize the lore there and not allow it to be simply taught. The typical example of that are abilities - Second Sight, Animal Ken and Sihr are all examples of stuff that can be taught which, with the gift penalty, wouldn't be able to be directly learned by the researcher but would generate insight from a teaching season.
Exactly. For there to be insights for hermetic magic theory, first, what they wrote needs to deviate from hermetic theory. This incidentally includes a few non-standard canon spells.
Yes, go straight to the original research rules and forget the integration rules if you're working from standard material. The point of integration rules is to force you to locate new stuff, not work from a Bonisagus magic theory primer.
But could a magus gain insights into the Mysteries or special abilities of other Houses? For example, could he learn something about Faerie Magic by studying a Merinita's lab texts, or about Verditius Magic by investigating an enchanted item commissioned from a Verditius magus?
I agree that simply reading standard Hermetic texts shouldn't automatically provide insights into unrelated Virtues. The source should contain knowledge that is actually relevant to what the researcher is trying to understand.
However, I also think there should be some distinction between finding relevant sources of knowledge and having to resort to original research. A researcher should actively seek out the specific knowledge he wants to integrate, whether through texts, other magi, magical items, or even traditions outside the Order.
I may be biased, but I like the idea that there should be some effort involved in finding suitable sources, rather than simply reading books from the covenant library and passively accumulating insights as the character progresses through the Arts.
Of course, the first insight might come from something already available in the covenant library. But I don't think the library should be the character's sole source of insights when it comes to acquiring an entirely new ability, magical technique, or Mystery. Seeking out the knowledge itself should be part of the research process.
For Farie magic, I would say that any lab text or enchanted item that includes those spell guidelines would certainly count as a source of Insight.
And I would agree that any enchanted item created by a Verditius would have the associated insights in it.
The one interesting would be some of the minor hermetic Bjorner virtues, specifically active sensory magic; appearently, they were originally intended to be fully folded into Hermetic theory, but Bonisagus only got around to integrating the passive versions.
With that in mind, it would certainly be a story element to start integrating the House virtues of the various Mystery Cults, and would likely start a debate at Grand Tribunal if someone (for example) presented a fait acomplit of "Yeah, I've fully integrated (say) Virditius runes; here's the tractus." Such things get put in the Book of Grudges, I believe.
If the source is relevant. So, say, if you get lab texts that are D: Until, sure! That's insight. Items crafted by a Verditius, covered with runes, would probably cover the runic parts of it. Whether both minor virtues are one or several breakthroughs, however, and whether they can all "easily" be obtained is a different question. I'm not sure you could learn the faerie attunement of Faerie Magic and the crafting aspect of Verditius Runes simply from a labtext.
It should be noted that if the House in question figures out you are trying to reverse engineer their Mysteries, they are going to be angry, like War angry. Learn the runes, earn a House wide Vendetta. Decipher Faerie Magic, experience Faerie curses.
Same as with any Mystery Cult actually. Possible exception for House Criamon, that might be more individual, case by case
One of the Veriditus inner mysteries (how to make automata) has already been released to the public. The offending / defecting mage was declared 'orbus' and the house talks smack about him -- but there has not been a War.
[Edit:] My memory seems to have failed me; Icilius was killed in a War as a direct result of releasing a House mystery. I will note that mages can now take the mystery virtue without having to belong to house Veriditus -- and do not suffer from Hubris. There are probably big story hooks to be had here, but (again, relying upon my known-to-be-faulty memory) taking this mystery does not seem to carry an instant-death penalty. [/Edit]
You may want to re-read the story. "The House ruthlessly dealt with Icilius; nearly a dozen Verditius magi declared Wizard’s War against the traitor. Icilius was hunted down and slain, but the damage was done."
I have been thinking about the premise of acquiring passive insights by reading valid fonts and came with some questions:
Should Insight-bearing texts have an additional value?
If some books or Lab Texts can provide Insights, should they be worth more Build Points when a covenant is created? They would offer more than ordinary instruction: they could help a researcher make progress toward a Breakthrough, potentially reducing the time and resources needed to find suitable sources.
How common should these sources be in covenant libraries?
It seems reasonable that older covenants might have accumulated texts containing Insights over generations of research. A Spring covenant, on the other hand, might have few such resources.
But should we expect libraries to contain a variety of Insight sources simply because many magi have worked there over the years? Or should these sources be relatively rare, reflecting the fact that they are usually the result of deliberate research?
Okay, trying to engage but personally i am still seeing this as highly situational. Need specifics. No amount of reading is going to provide enough Insight to make the Gentle Gift a breakthrough, as an example.
Still, answering general questions.
No. I would rule as a Storyguide, if you are using the text as a soirce of Insight for Research/Integration purposes, you are forgoing the capacity to use it as Experience Source. You can use the Tractatus to raise your arts or use as insight to incorporate say, a Mystery Guideline into Hermetic Magic but not both. As a single use resource I'd argue it should not nessicarily cost more.
It varys. Covenants that are homes to Mystery Cults probably have more, even in the form of Lab Texts but if it were that easy to use them for Insight, some Bonisagus would have definitely tried by now and have had some kind of success.
At a bare a minimum, I think the Bonisagi would have tried to absorb/Intergrate Merinita’s Faerie Magic by now if it was that easy.