What cow story?
Incredible, I never thought you could do that
You're being too hard on the poor Hiems. He does have a positive presence, too, so the difference is probably not that great, if there is one (and unless the guy spend a lot of points on Improved Characteristics, or dumped some other stats, they probably have the same presence).
As per the body, well, Arnuld had great Str and Sta as Conan, that did not make him any hotter... save in the eyes of those that like it. Conversely, both Jude Law and Orlando Bloom aren't beefy, especially compared to Chris Hemsworth or Chris Evans. Yet, some women will prefer the later, some the former.
=> Str and Sta aren't important per se. Its your other stats that tell if these look good (Hemsworth, Bloom) or not (Arnuld, Christopher Walken). Hiems and Georges are probably in about the same league, but with different styles.
But the most funny thing? Hiems does have Envied Beauty. So, even if he loaded on Great Charac and Improved Charac on presence, Georges will probably react badly to him... While Hiems, being as he is, will certainly perceive Georges as being so much better than him